Had been Purple Bull proper to drop De Vries from his AlphaTauri race seat?

For the primary time since Jolyon Palmer in 2017, a Components 1 driver who started a season has been dropped by his crew with out reaching the ultimate race for efficiency causes.

Whereas the very fact Nyck de Vries was beneath stress because of his underwhelming begin to his first full season in Components 1 was well-known, Purple Bull’s resolution to tug the set off to interchange him at their AlphaTauri junior crew with third driver Daniel Ricciardo lower than half manner into the season caught many abruptly.

It’s in no way the primary time that Purple Bull have made a daring transfer to interchange a driver in the midst of a season – simply ask Daniil Kvyat and Pierre Gasly. However whereas Kvyat had 21 races at Purple Bull and Gasly 12 earlier than being moved apart for his or her replacements, De Vries has had fewer grands prix than each of them.

Not like Kvyat or Gasly, De Vries was not a Purple Bull prospect, having by no means been a member of the Purple Bull junior driver programme throughout his junior profession. However the 2019 F2 champion had robust Mercedes connections, having been Mercedes’ reserve driver for various years and impressed by stepping in for Alexander Albon at Williams throughout final 12 months’s Italian Grand Prix.

So have Purple Bull forged apart De Vries too unexpectedly in his rookie season, or did he fail to point out that he had the power to compete at a excessive sufficient stage to deserve his place as one of many 20 drivers with the privilege of a seat on the Components 1 grid?

Workforce mate comparability: De Vries vs Tsunoda


The obvious proof of why De Vries deserved to lose his place in F1 is to easily take a look at the championship standings. Regardless of the AlphaTauri being often close to the again of the sector over the beginning of the season, Tsunoda has taken two factors finishes to this point this season, whereas De Vries was one in all solely two drivers to depart Silverstone nonetheless with none factors from the primary ten rounds.

There’s additionally the very fact De Vries was soundly crushed by the youthful Tsunoda in each consultant statistic. Tsunoda out-qualified De Vries 8-2 within the first ten rounds, spending virtually 400 extra laps forward of De Vries than he spent behind him. De Vries additionally failed to succeed in Q3 as soon as, one thing Tsunoda managed in each Baku and Monaco.

Lastly, there have been the errors. In Baku, De Vries managed to crash out of qualifying on Friday, conflict with Tsunoda within the dash race in Baku on Saturday, earlier than crashing out of the grand prix on Sunday. His conflict with Kevin Magnussen in Canada was clumsy, then he pushed him off in Austria to earn a penalty. All of it made him appear like an F2 driver, not an skilled a number of single-seater champion.

In opposition to

When trying over the primary half of the season, it’s laborious to discover a satisfying physique of proof to counsel that De Vries deserved to be unceremoniously jettisoned from the F1 grid in the course of the summer season break, not to mention two rounds earlier than it.

His efficiency relative to crew mate Tsunoda over their races collectively was clearly inferior, with Tsunoda being forward of him in each attainable metric, however Tsunoda had the benefit of being in his third full season in Components 1, with that additional expertise counting for lots. In any case, Tsunoda himself was largely unable to match his extra skilled crew mate Gasly throughout his first two seasons.

De Vries was additionally deprived by how the AlphaTauri was clearly falling additional down the order because the season went on. Whereas Williams improved with their upgrades and have grow to be common factors scorers, the AlphaTauri has grow to be one of many slower vehicles on the grid, with their main upgrades for Silverstone having minimal affect on their efficiency and limiting De Vries’ alternatives to impress.

I say

Nyck de Vries deserved extra then simply ten grands prix in an AlphaTauri to point out he was deserving of a spot on the F1 grid past 2023. Particularly in comparison with another drivers who’ve been given the chance to compete in full seasons during the last decade.

Nikita Mazepin, Haas, Losail International Circuit, 2021Mazepin bought twice the variety of races De Vries hadYes, his Baku weekend was one of many worst performances of the season up to now. But when a sure former Haas driver bought a full 12 months in Components 1 – and was alleged to have a second – than De Vries greater than deserved a full season to point out he may study from his early errors, discover some kind and make his case to remain on in 2024. Even when Purple Bull would determine to interchange him on the finish of the 12 months with a rookie the preferred of Liam Lawson or Ayumu Iwasa, at the least De Vries would have had simply over 20 weekends of alternative – a a lot tougher scenario to complain about.

In the end, it appears like De Vries being dropped is lots much less in regards to the driver himself and his performances than it’s about who he’s being changed with. A driver who has way more expertise and success than De Vries in addition to being way more marketable than him. It’s tough to see how De Vries will find yourself again on the grid as a full time driver in future. However whereas he lastly bought his likelihood in F1 on the age of 28, he deserved extra races than he finally bought.

You say

Do you agree with Purple Bull’s resolution to drop Nyck de Vries from his AlphaTauri race seat?

  • Strongly disagree (21%)
  • Barely disagree (16%)
  • Neither agree nor disagree (12%)
  • Barely agree (26%)
  • Strongly agree (25%)

Whole Voters: 68

Loading ... Loading …

A F1 Triviaaccount is required to be able to vote. Should you would not have one, register an account right here or learn extra about registering right here. When this ballot is closed the consequence might be displayed as a substitute of the voting kind.

Debates and polls

Browse all debates and polls

Previous Technical: AlphaTauri debut a heavily-revised automotive in Silverstone
Next Crimson Bull completes showrun with Perez in Madrid